Problem 2

The Hill reaction dissects photosynthesis. (a) Write the overall equation of plant photosynthesis, reducing

\ce{CO2}

\{\ce{CH2O}\}

. (b) Hill found that isolated chloroplasts do not evolve

\ce{O2}

in light even with

\ce{CO2}

, but do so upon adding potassium ferrioxalate

\ce{K3[Fe(C2O4)3]}

(with excess oxalate) without

\ce{CO2}

. Give the oxidant and reducing agent in natural photosynthesis and in the Hill reaction. (c) Hill measured evolved

\ce{O2}

with haemoglobin (Hb binds

\ce{O2}

1:1, initial

[\text{Hb}] = 0.6 \times 10^{-4}

mol dm

^{-3}

); at

[\ce{Fe^{III}}] = 2.0 \times 10^{-4}

mol dm

^{-3}

the HbO

_2

fraction saturates at about 75 %. Estimate the Fe/

\ce{O2}

ratio, write the Hill reaction equation, and calculate its

\Delta G

T = 298

p(\ce{O2}) = 1

mmHg, pH = 8, standard concentrations of other species (

E^{\circ}

\ce{O2 + 4H+ + 4e- -> 2H2O}

+1.23 V;

\ce{[Fe(C2O4)3]^{3-} + e- -> [Fe(C2O4)3]^{4-}}

+0.05 V). Is it spontaneous? (d) Isolated chloroplasts were irradiated 2 h with 672 nm light of 0.503 mJ s

^{-1}

, producing 47.6 mm

^3

\ce{O2}

(10 °C, 740 mmHg). Calculate the quantum requirement (photons per electron transferred). (e) Conclusions: are water oxidation and

\ce{CO2}

reduction spatially separated? Is

\ce{O2}

produced from

\ce{CO2}

? Does water oxidation require light? Do most chlorophylls participate directly? Does each photon transfer one electron?

Step 1 of 5: Overall equations and redox roles

← Previous Next →

Intuition

Hill's key insight: chloroplasts can oxidise water without $\ce{CO2}$ , proving the oxygen source is water.

\ce{CO2 + H2O -> {CH2O} + O2};\quad \text{natural: oxidant } \ce{CO2},\ \text{reductant } \ce{H2O};\quad \text{Hill: oxidant } \ce{[Fe(C2O4)3]^{3-}},\ \text{reductant } \ce{H2O}

Analysis

In both cases water is the electron donor ( $\ce{O2}$ comes from $\ce{H2O}$ , not $\ce{CO2}$ ); only the terminal oxidant changes, from $\ce{CO2}$ to ferrioxalate.